Showing posts with label Drama. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Drama. Show all posts

Monday, October 10, 2011

Real Steel (2011)

 
The greatest achievement in Shawn Levy’s Real Steel is building the world of robot boxing.  The term “robot boxing” sounds incredibly stupid when you hear it and flashes of Rock ‘Em, Sock ‘Em Robots and the failed TV show Battlebots come to mind.  But Levy does a tremendous job for showing not just the hi-tech wonder of the World Boxing Organization (WBO), but he takes us to the back-alleys, run-down theme parks, and country fairs where a punching robot and its owner can make some cash and win some glory.  Paired with well-choreographed fights that wisely make heavy use of animatronics and practical effects, Real Steel almost has an unbeatable combination.  But the clunky storytelling and awful performance from child actor Dakota Goyo stop the movie from landing a knock-out punch (I promise I’ll try to keep the boxing puns to a minimum).


Former boxer Charlie Keaton (Hugh Jackman) has had to step outside the ring to make his living off the boxing robots that basically took his job.  However, his impatience, ineptitude, and poor business acumen have left him heavily in debt and scrambling to find any robot that can put up a fight.  Lucky for Charlie, his ex-girlfriend dies and he finds a chance to make some quick money by selling custody of his estranged son Max (Goyo) to Max’s aunt (Hope Davis) and her rich husband (James Rebhorn).  Charlie cuts a deal to take Max over the summer while the aunt and uncle go to Italy and when they come back, Charlie gets the rest of his money, Max doesn’t have to put up with his deadbeat father, and everyone is happy.  But then Max and Charlie get behind Atom, a sparring robot they found in a dump and they start working him up through the ranks of the robot boxing world.  Unsurprisingly, father and son finally begin to bond with Max providing the voice of reason against Charlie’s general incompetence.


Real Steel gets serious credit for not pulling any punches (sorry) when it comes to Charlie’s character.  He’s a gigantic ass-hole and Jackman and Levy have no qualms about turning us against him at the beginning of the movie.  We’re pushed right up to the line of caring about whether Charlie gets redeemed or not, but by making us root for Charlie’s symbol, Atom—a broken down robot that no one thinks will make it because he’s built to take punishment but not dish it out—we get on board with the Rocky story.

It’s an easy story to tell, but Real Steel has a hell of a time trying to get the words out.  If the movie isn’t walking through the robot-boxing world or showing a fight scene, then we either have to drag our feet through the predictable relationship arc between Charlie and Max, or we have to waste time with Charlie’s unnecessary and underdeveloped love-interest/exposition-machine Bailey (Evangeline Lilly).  The Charlie-Max relationship would at least be palatable if Goyo weren’t so terrible.  He never misses an opportunity to remind you that he’s a child actor.  I didn’t know anyone was looking for the next Jake Lloyd, but they’ve certainly found him.  Jackman deserves a lot of credit for not trying to smooth over Charlie’s rough edges, but Goyo’s performance is a serious blow to a movie that relies on the father-son relationship as its emotional core.


But the story and characters almost become an afterthought when we step into the ring.  Rather than having the WBO dominate and own every part of the robot boxing world, the movie takes Max and Charlie on the road and we get to see them fight in different arenas.  By expanding the world, we believe more in the concept of “robot boxing” and look forward to seeing how fights are set up, the different bots from varying locales, and how each bot has its own fighting style.  The design of the robots is terrific and I particularly liked the look of Atom who has the slightest hint of a smile on his wide-eyed face.  Levy also made the smart decision to rely on practical effects.  CGI tends to make objects look weightless, and that could have killed Real Steel.  Instead, Levy uses CGI when he needs the robots to be quick and light on their feet, but then relies on practical effects for most of the hits and the close-ups.  The only downside to this thoughtfully crafted world is that when we’re taken out of it, we notice that nothing else in the world has advanced in 15 years except for HP computers. Every company will keep same logo and slogans they have now.  It’s a bit disappointing since the production designers could have had some fun predicting what future logos would look like, but the marketing teams for corporations like Sprint and Microsoft have strict parameters on their product placement, so it’s tough to hold the filmmakers accountable on this small issue.

Story and characters are the most important elements of almost any movie, and they’re serviceable enough to make Real Steel function.  There’s not a disinterest in those crucial elements as much as poor execution through sloppy dialogue and an exceedingly poor casting decision for a major role.  Thankfully, the movie plays to its strengths by bringing the audience into a rich and fascinating world filled with exhilarating fight scenes.  Real Steel is much like Atom: clunky and a little flat-footed but charming enough to stay in the fight.




Monday, October 3, 2011

Inception (2010)

“True inspiration is impossible to fake,” explains a character in Christopher Nolan’s existentialist heist film Inception.  If that’s the case, then Inception is one of the most honest films ever made.  Nolan has crafted a movie that’s beyond brilliant and layered both narratively and thematically.  It requires the audience to take in a collection of rules, exceptions, locations, jobs, and abilities in order to understand the text, let alone the fascinating subtext.  Nolan’s magnum opus is the first major blockbuster in over a decade that’s demanded intense viewer concentration, raised thoughtful and complex ideas, and wrapped everything all in a breathlessly exciting action film.  Inception may be complicated, but simply put it’s one of the best movies of the year.

Inception requires so much exposition that a lesser director would have forced theaters to distribute pamphlets to audience members in order to explain the complicated world he’s developed.  During my first draft of this view, I realized I had spent three paragraphs simply trying to explain the plot.  I will simply avoid this exposition and present the movie’s basic premise.  Inception centers on a team of individuals led by an “extractor” named Cobb (Leonardo DiCaprio) who, through the use of a special device, construct the dreams of a target and use those dreams to implant an idea so that the target will make a decision beneficial to the individual who hired the team.  To say that scratches the surface would be an insult to both scratches and surfaces.  But since it takes Nolan about fifty minutes to set everything up, I hope you’ll forgive my brevity.

Why is it so difficult to explain the plot in depth?  First, I don’t want to spoil you.  Secondly, the film layers dreams on top of dreams to the point where a unique keepsake called a “totem” is required in order to inform a character as to whether or not he or she is still dreaming.  Then you have people in particular roles like “The Architect”, “The Forger”, and “The Chemist” in order to pull off the job.  Furthermore, dreams have rules: dying in a dream forces the dreamer to wake up, delving too deeply into a mind can cause an eternal slumber called “Limbo”, using memories to construct dreams is dangerous because it can blur the line between dreams and reality.  In addition, intruding in the dreams of another will cause the dreamer’s “projections” (human representations created by the dreamer) to attack the intruders like white blood cells going after an infection.  And these explanations only represent a fraction of the terminology, rules, exceptions, or details that are necessary for creating the world of Inception.


But it’s not a confusing movie if you provide it with your full attention.  There are a lot of summer movies that ask you turn off your brain and enjoy the persistent-vegetative-state ride.  Inception is not one of those movies. There’s a lot to take in, but the imaginative and thoughtful delivery of exposition keeps the viewer riveted despite the amount of information required in order to understand the premise, setting, and plot.

It tends to be the case that lots of rules create lots of loopholes.  Filmmakers can use these to cheat and let audiences fill in the leaps of logics. But Inception always plays fair.  It will twist your mind but it’s not a film built on twists.  It’s a film built on possibilities and the boldness of pursuing those possibilities.  On my first viewing, the film experienced a technical malfunction where a misplaced reel skipped the movie forward by twenty minutes and then played the scene upside down and in reverse.  Inception had already sent the audience through such a strange narrative labyrinth that almost everyone in the theater wasn’t sure if something had gone wrong or if Nolan had just made another bold decision.

The film deserves, demands, and rewards repeat viewings, but from your first viewing you can grasp the events on screen and how they interact with each other as long as you force yourself to be an active viewer.  But with set pieces so intricate, so jaw-dropping, and so breathtaking, you’ll find that there’s no exertion needed to stay focused.  You’ll already be swept up in the whirlwind.


Inception features one of the best fight scenes of all-time.  Take a moment to consider that: in the entire history of cinema, of every fight scene that has ever taken place, the one in this movie is among the best.  Watching a fight without gravity is incredible.  It’s not like in The Matrix where a character can defy gravity if they choose.  The fight scene in Inception has no gravity to defy and Arthur (played by Joseph Gordon-Levitt), the team’s point man, has to figure out how to achieve his objective while fending off projections.  I can only hope that someday in the distant future, when people with free time are on a space station in zero-gravity, they will re-enact this scene.  In the meantime, Nolan’s spectacular visual effects will have to suffice.

With the exception of one set piece (which I’ll get to in a moment), the action scenes in Inception are spectacular.  Visually lush and imaginative, Nolan transforms car chases into countdowns, fistfights into puzzles, and shootouts into…well, shootouts.  There’s a mission on a snowy mountainside that doesn’t work as well as the other set pieces because there’s a poor sense of location, a lack of visual diversity, and sloppy editing.  But that doesn’t really halt or hurt the film because Nolan brilliantly placed the car chase, the fistfight, and the shootout on top of each other.  You would think this would cause action fatigue, but by cutting between three set pieces and having what happens in one set piece affect the others, the action climax of Inception isn’t exhausting—it’s exhilarating.


You can be the best action director around but you can only get so far if you lack characters worth caring about.  With Inception, every character not only has a particular skill and task, but has a personality that mirrors their job description.

We learn about the characters of Inception not from long monologues about their past or even (with the exception of Cobb) delving into their dreams and memories.  We learn about them by how they interact with each other.  The small moments between Arthur and Eames, “The Forger” (Tom Hardy) indicate years of working on j tolerating each other on jobs but with no animosity between the two.  Neophyte “Architect” Ariadne (Ellen Page) is a total jerk towards Cobb, but she’s the only one who’s willing to cut through his bullshit.  Cobb’s relationship with his wife Mal (Marion Cotillard) is the heart of Inception.  The interactions among the supporting characters are standard for a well-made action movie, but the relationship between Cobb and Mal is yet another reason why Inception stands apart.

DiCaprio will take some flack for playing a similar character to his one in Shutter Island from earlier this year.  Both Cobb and Teddy Daniels have become separated from their families, suffer from unbearable guilt, and have a tough time handling the nature of reality.  Here’s another similarity: DiCaprio is great in both movies.  I wouldn’t worry about him getting typecast as tragic-figure-with-tenuous-grasp-on-reality-as-a-result-of-intense-guilt-and-regret.

Two of the film’s stars will (hopefully) find their careers at the next level after this movie opens.  Their names are “Joseph Gordon-Levitt” and “Tom Hardy”.  Gordon-Levitt has excelled at playing lost boys, tortures souls, and recently a charming male lead in (500) Days of Summer.  You can now add “bad-ass blockbuster action star” to that list.  Gordon-Levitt’s versatility is why I will be excited for any movie that lists him as one of its stars.

Hardy’s critically acclaimed performance in Nicolas Winding Refn’s Bronson brought him to Hollywood’s attention.  His performance in Inception will bring him the attention of countries.  He brings a light-hearted touch to the film and while the script forces other characters to remain serious, Eames takes a more laid back approach to the mind-heist game.  But he’s not comic relief and he’s not around to comment on absurd circumstances.  Like everyone in the cast, he’s there to help the team achieve their goal (although the script functions in such a way that you could see each character as a representation of a specific idea).

The only actor who’s a little shaky is Ken Watanabe who plays Saito, the team’s employer.  His performance is great.  He pulls off the impressive feat of being threatening without being menacing.  The only problem is that Watanabe’s Japanese accent is so thick that it’s sometimes difficult to make out what he’s saying.  In a movie where the dialogue is as delicately crafted as the rest of the film, it’s unfortunate to lose a few lines due to something as simple as pronunciation.  And it’s only noticeable because everything in Inception is so finely crafted.

The physical scope of this movie is astounding.  Worlds fall on top of each other, a freight train can burst onto a city street, hotels can lose all gravity, and everything that we know is impossible appears completely natural.  It’s not enough to say that the cinematography is gorgeous, or that the sound design is sensational, or that this is one of composer Hans Zimmer’s all-time best scores.  There aren’t “supporting” elements in Inception.  Just as the film layers its narrative structure and thematic subtext, so it does with its technical elements.  You will notice the cinematography and the art direction and the sounds and the score.  It’s like hearing beautiful solos mixed together in a glorious anthem.


As you’ve probably guessed, when I said at the beginning of this review that Inception was the first movie in over a decade to mix breathtaking action with thoughtful subtext, I was referring to 1999′s The Matrix.  The comparisons are inevitable.  Both movies deal with the nature of reality combined with pulse-pounding set pieces that will be included in any action-scene highlight reel.  But The Matrix is a freshman level course compared to the doctorate held by Inception, and it has nothing to do with how far special effects have come in ten years.  It’s about taking multiple genres, settings, ideas, emotions, and questions and weaving them into a rich tapestry that will have folks talking long after the credits roll.  But then you throw in those advanced special effects and you have a summer blockbuster that will blow your mind.

Monday, September 26, 2011

Abduction (2011)

So I made a few jokes at the fact I was going to see this movie, sure it was a free ticket but I’m not that interested in Taylor Lautner’s abs. But in all honesty I hope to be impressed by movies that are out of my comfort zone. As I sat down to watch this movie I hoped that this would be like I Am Number Four, and entertaining enough to get me over the all teen drama this movie would surely have.

Okay the surprise here was I was kind of into the movie at the beginning. It wasn’t my cup of tea but I could see other people getting a kick out of it. Taylor Lautner was okay, and there was a slow build up. It gave us some character development. Not a hell of a lot but enough to get people to give a damn about them. But then maybe a quarter of the way through there is a line that signifies a wave of stupidity that’s about to hit. A wave that washes away any good will the movie was building. That line? “There’s a bomb in the oven.” Basically it is the first plot point that makes little sense, and is only there to add an action beat.


This movies biggest problem is the script. It’s written in clichés and has some of the worst dialogue I’ve heard in a while. By the end of the movie there were people behind me laughing at nearly every line being uttered by the characters. What was worse was they were being uttered by good actors who were turning in some of the worst performances I’ve seen them do. It seems that plot is sacrificed for the sake of action, and even then the action isn’t all that to write home about. Though Taylor Lautner does show glimmers of potential in becoming a fully fledged action star in the future.


Taylor Lautner is competent in acting in the beginning. All he needs to do is act like a teenager and show a little inner turmoil. But it’s all pretty one note. When the action kicks in however he does seem to have a problem transitioning from emotion to emotion. It’s almost like he can’t actually show two emotions at once. I do think he has potential in becoming an action star but this will probably take time. As for the other actors they all are weighed down with the script and only three manage to overcome it. Jason Isaacs, Maria Bello and Alfred Molina, with Maria Bello being the best of the trio. I really dug Alfred Molina but his character of Burton is written in pure cliché and I’ve seen this character so much that as much personality he brought to the role, I knew exactly where it was all headed.

Abduction was a disappointment because the first quarter of the movie did promise that it would be at least a competent movie. I think fans of Taylor Lautner might still like the movie, and find enough action to not be bored. However I saw first hand the demographic of this movie start to reject it with laughter which isn’t a very good sign.

Thursday, September 22, 2011

Kill List (2011)

There are horror movies that jump out at you from the first scene and grab you by the short and curlies before the title even hits the screen. Then there are the horror movies that sneak up to you, deliberately lulling you into a false sense of security before pulling the rug out from under you, so that while the overall scare count is lower, the big moments cut deeper (think Audition or the original version of The Wicker Man). Kill List falls into the latter category and the blood thirsty viewers at The Toronto Film Festival’s Midnight Madness program are sure to find themselves coddled and devastating, leaving the theater feeling like they’ve been chatted up and punched in the face. It’s a good flick, one that should find itself a healthy cult audience upon theatrical release. Hit the jump for the review.

kill-list-imageFor the entire first act, Kill List almost feels like a kitchen sink tale of British misery, the kind played to perfection by filmmakers like Mike Leigh and Alan Clarke. We’re introduced to a middle-aged married couple mid-argument. The husband Jay (Neil Maskell) has been out of work for 8 months and their bills are piling up while their bank account drains away. His wife Shel (Myanna Buring) berates him for buying copious amounts of wine for a dinner party instead of toilet paper, but that booze is put to good use when his friend Gal (Michael Smiley) and his mysterious new girlfriend Fiona (Emma Fryer) arrive. An ugly screaming match of a dinner unfolds and as a result, Jay agrees to go back to work with Gal. The catch is that they end up being hit men and their latest job proves to be a bit darker than expected when Jay is required to provide a little blood for the contract and the first assignment on their kill list is to take out a priest. Revealing more would be unfair, but rest assured that a terrifying cult is involved.


The film comes from director Ben Wheatley who made strong debut with his zero budget crime/comedy Down Terrace that liberally mixed genres like it was going out of style. Kill List is a similar beast, transforming from harsh family drama into a viciously violent hitman tale, and finally into a possibly satanic horror movie (which was really hanging in the background all along for those paying attention). However, Wheatley doesn’t play with genres to create a self-conscious cinematic mixtape like Quentin Tarantino or Edgar Wright. It’s merely a means of misdirection. He knows that audiences will expect a movie to turn out a certain way based on genre expectations and uses that to lead them down false paths. When the first blast of violence occurs via a blunt hammer and a welcoming skull, it hits hard. The scene would be a standout shock even if the entire film had been bloody up until then. Without warning it feels twice as harsh and suddenly you don’t trust the filmmaker. When things enter full on horror mode in the last act, there’s a total uncertainty about where things could possibly go and when the finale arrives you’ll feel shattered. It’s brilliantly structured and for a writer/director only in his sophomore outing, this is a remarkably confident, controlled, and brutal piece of filmmaking.


In a way, Kill List is a horror movie almost by default. It’s certainly chilling and even scarring, but not exactly what you’d expect from a movie with that label slapped on the box. For one thing, it’s shot in a handheld realist style with improvised performances. That’s not the expected aesthetic and tone of the oft-storyboard genre, but it’s in the unexpected where the best scares lie and the movie is filled with the unexpected in every conceivable sense. I doubt Kill List will be embraced as a genre classic. It’s just too weird and twisted for that and by design leaves the audience feeling abused and battered when the credits roll, an experience that understandably not everyone enjoys (personally, I’m somewhat of a glutton for punishment when it comes to this shit). However, for those willing to take the ride, I can promise you’ve seen nothing quite like it and cult status is all but assure. Sure, there are bits and pieces of Kill List that are reminiscent of other films and genres, but they’ve never been combined quite like this before and the culminative impact is pretty impressive. If you want to feel worn out, beaten, and ultimately elated by a film, you’re not going to do any better than Kill List. This is one for all the intelligent sick puppies out there who don’t mind seeing cinematic ingenuity and gag inducing gore magically mixed together. Those folks are going to cheer and vomit with sheer delight.

Drive

Nicolas Winding Refn’s Drive works across time and genre. It’s set in present-day Los Angeles, uses an 80s score and soundtrack, features a tragic 50s noir protagonist, and wraps everyone up in archetypical figures that manage to feel fresh through strong performances and gorgeous cinematography. It’s a film that confidently walks the line between alienating its audience with bold choices but it never strays so far into the obtuse or the strange that you lose the hard-boiled crime story simmering underneath. It constantly challenges the audience to look away with its intensity, its thoughtfulness, and its brutality, but it’s too damn entertaining to look away.


Like all great noir protagonists, the Driver (Ryan Gosling) has a code and it makes him good at his job. He’s a stunt-driver by day, but at night his true driving talent shines when he works as a wheelman. He can outrun his pursuers when necessary, but his real strength is in his reserve and patience in the face of danger. While he attempts to keep others at a distance, he eventually warms up to his neighbor Irene (Carey Mulligan) and her young son Benecio. When Irene’s husband Standard Gabriel (Oscar Isaac) gets out of prison, he comes home and owes protection money to bad folks. The Driver decides he’ll help Gabriel on a job in order to protect Irene and Benecio, but matters then fall apart as shady figures Nino (Ron Perlman) and Bernie Rose (Albert Brooks) come into play. Like all great noir protagonists, The Driver breaks from his code to do something honorable and it leads to his downfall.


In recent years, Gosling has become one of Hollywood’s most respected actors and in Drive he turns in a career-best performance. He plays the characters’ emotions close to the vest and tries to convey as much as possible with minor expressions. What’s remarkable is that he’s able to craft such a rich and interesting character without playing it all on the surface and then has to show how the identity deteriorates over the course of the film. It’s a bizarre mix of nobility, detachment, and violent madness but Gosling brings it all together to make an utterly compelling character who holds your attention in every single frame.

Telling a cinematic story from the POV of its protagonist isn’t simply a matter of doing a POV-shot and Gosling isn’t the only one who inhabits the Driver’s calm exterior and explosive rage. Refn matches Gosling’s performance shot for shot and it’s beautiful to see an actor’s delivery and a director’s vision work in such perfect harmony. However, when the Driver starts to emotionally unravel and struggles to understand his own identity, Refn keeps his cool and manages to balance the insanity of the action with the pathos of the main character.


The film is filled with great performances but despite having heavyweights like Carey Mulligan and Bryan Cranston in the cast, the biggest characters are played by Gosling and Brooks. They’re the real powerhouses and I have to give Brooks his due. You have never seen him play a character like this before and he’s tremendous as a villain who’s beguiling, intelligent, and absolutely ruthless. In some ways, The Driver and Rose are two sides of the same coin in terms of their personalities and their ethics, but that’s an essay for another time.

Plenty of essays could be written about Drive. It’s the rare film where I immediately wanted to watch it again, but would like to pause it and scribble down plenty of notes. So many great ideas swirl around hard-boiled crime story and you can get lost dissecting it as a character piece, as a product of genre cinema, or even breaking down the cleverness of the cinematography. Sometimes the visuals become overt like when the lights in the elevator dim and the Driver and Irene have their first kiss. Other times it sneaks in like when Irene tells the Driver that her husband is getting out of jail and we can see a red light reflected off their faces. Every shot is purposeful and well-constructed that you just want to take the movie frame-by-frame and sit in awe.

I’ve been a fan of Refn ever since watch the Pusher trilogy and Bronson, but his American-debut is his strongest film yet. As he did with his previous films, he takes a simple genre (in this case an action-crime flick) and twists its conventions and rethinks its possibilities and comes away with a magnificent reinvention. Drive is an exhilarating ride where the thrills are as raw and intense as the emotions.

Anonymous (2011)

In Anonymous, Edward de Vere, the Earl of Oxford (Rhys Ifans) tells young playwright Ben Jonson (Sebastian Armesto), “All artists have something to say because otherwise they’d just make shoes.”  It’s a funny quote when you consider that director Roland Emmerich’s previous filmography is mainly comprised of brainless blockbusters like Independence Day, The Day After Tomorrow, and 2012.  Anonymous, a political thriller wrapped in a conspiracy theory, could not be further from those movies and Emmerich sets out like a man with something to prove.  There are no monsters, aliens, cataclysms, and the only explosion is the destruction of the Globe Theatre, which actually did burn to the ground in 1613.  The film plays fast and loose with most historical facts (including why the Globe burned down), but it manages to craft an intriguing period piece before getting bogged down in political intrigue and tearing down historical figures.

anonymous-movie-poster-01The movie begins on a stage where an unnamed man (Derek Jacobi) presents the audience with the controversial theory that William Shakespeare did not write his own plays. As actors fill the stage, the camera zooms in and we’re transported back to 1613 London where Jonson is running from armed guards and attempting to hide stacks of paper.  He manages to hide the documents in a chest inside the Globe and then burn the theater to the ground before he’s captured and brought in for interrogation.


The story then cuts back five years and we see Jonson as a struggling playwright with Shakespeare (Rafe Spall) in his company of actors.  The political landscape of England is changing as the health of the elderly Queen Elizabeth (Vanessa Redgrave) begins to fade and two sides cast their eyes towards seizing the throne.  On the one side are the Queen’s chief advisor William Cecil (David Thewlis) and his son Robert (Edward Hogg) who support King James of Scotland as the heir/puppet.  The other faction supports the Earl of Essex (Sam Reid) who is heavily rumored to be the Queen’s bastard son.  Fearing an all out civil war, Edward de Vere wants to use his unpublished plays to nudge the public against the Cecils—who are his adopted family—and towards the Earl of Essex.  Since to do so publicly would result in serve consequences, de Vere asks that his plays be submitted anonymously through Jonson.  However, after a rousing performance of Henry V, the audience demands to know the playwright and Shakespeare seizes the opportunity to take the credit.

Thrown on top of all of this is a storyline taking place thirty years prior where we see a young Edward (Jamie Campbell Bower) trying to keep his writing a secret from the puritanical Cecil household.  However, his plays and poems win the heart of young Queen Elizabeth (Joely Richardson) and the two carry on a secret affair which will have both short and long-term repercussions.  If those storylines were enough, there’s also Jonson’s anger at Shakespeare’s fraud, Shakespeare’s abuse of his newfound fame, and de Vere’s relationship with the Earl of Southampton (Xavier Samuel).


That’s a lot of plot, a lot of characters, and for the first hour it Anonymous looks like it will be able to balance the complexities of the story while weaving in the thoughtful subtext about an artist’s work being more important than the artist.  The direction is self-assured, the cinematography is lush and filled with warm colors, and all of the storylines proceed and intertwine at a captivating pace.

But then you begin to realize you don’t really know any of the characters.  Everyone is made up of motives but with little motivation.  The Cecils want to control Elizabeth because they want power.  Jonson wants to bring down Shakespeare because Shakespeare is a buffoon whose massive ego is causing massive headaches for everyone else.  De Vere wants to use his plays to protect England, but we never quite see how most of his selections are influential.  Some of the characters are clear criticisms of either Robert or William Cecil, and the plays MacBeth and Hamlet have political undertones, but where’s the criticism in Romeo & Juliet?  And how does Shakespeare get access to A Midsummer’s Night Dream when we see De Vere perform the play for Elizabeth forty years earlier?  Anonymous keeps putting the cart in front of the horse.


The Shakespeare-as-Fraud angle is the hook of Anonymous and it offers the promising subtext, but Emmerich loses the thread by pursuing the political angle at the expense of all else.  We bounce between time periods, we bounce between political players, and the story begins to grind to a halt since the characters become secondary to the intrigue.  As the political story continues to build and a tragic element starts to seep into the plot, the Shakespeare angle becomes a distracting sideshow until Emmerich finally finds a reason to make it crucial to the film’s climax.  By the time de Vere finally makes the pen mightier than the sword, the fascinating creator/creation subtext has been lost.

Thankfully, the political intrigue and the world Emmerich has built are sturdy enough to hold our interest although the story would be far richer with better character development.  More problematic is taking the age’s two best-known figures: Queen Elizabeth I and William Shakespare, and making them downright loathsome.  At first, Shakespeare functions at the comic relief, but then he takes on a more sinister role and you’re left to wonder why the film needs him to be a villain.  More bizarre is how much hate the film reserves for Elizabeth.  Elizabeth I was revered as one of England’s greatest monarchs and she navigated her country through war and upheaval while keeping opposing countries at bay.  Anonymous thinks she’s a moron and a slut.  Elizabeth is easily manipulated by the Cecils and is given the reputation as a woman with secret bastard children and lovers floating around.  If this information were done to humanize Elizabeth, I could respect it, but these negative qualities are all we see of her.

Anonymous won’t make you drastically reevaluate your opinion of Roland Emmerich but he’s proved he can deliver an exciting movie which can be enjoyed without irony. Despite the stolid pacing of the second half and the weak characterization, the movie’s biggest saving grace is Shakespeare’s plays.  The most dramatic moments of Anonymous don’t come from the political backstabbing or secret romances but from hearing the Saint Crispin’s Day speech of Henry V, the “Now is the winter of our discontent” monologue from Richard III, and other famous moments that Shakespeare fans know by heart.  Whether you believe Shakespeare wrote his plays (he did) or if someone else was responsible (they weren’t), Anonymous acknowledges the power of “Words, words, words.”  Not a bad message from a director whose last film had a limo drive through a building.

Moneyball (2011)

The joy one gets from going to a baseball game is an intangible.  You can keep the foul ball you caught in the stands or the souvenir cap you got at the gate, but there’s no quantifying the thrill of seeing a walk-off home-run or watching a player make a diving catch or seeing a pitcher strike out the batter with bases loaded.  Oakland Athletics general manager Billy Beane (played by Brad Pitt) presented an anathema to the intangible by trying to quantify every play and every player.  The uproar against his plan was tremendous and oblivious.  The game had already been quantified in dollars, and the A’s didn’t have much of those.  What they did have was a willingness to rethink an unfair business to so they could have a shot at the championship.  Bennett Miller’s adaptation of Michael Lewis’ Moneyball takes the interesting ideas presented in the book and transforms them into a funny, dramatic, and captivating tale that can hold competing ideas simultaneously.


In 2001, the A’s reached the American League Division Series but were defeated by the New York Yankees.  The A’s had a payroll of $38 million to New York’s $114 million.  The A’s also had star players Jason Giambi, Johnny Damon, and Jason Isringhausen, all of who went into free agency at the end of the season and would garner a price tag out of the Atheletics’ budget.  Unable to get more money and desperate to win, Beane discovers Yale economics graduate Peter Brandt (Jonah Hill) and learns that every team in baseball is wasting their cash.  Too much has been placed on intangibles like looks, a good swing, and deceptive statistics like runs-batted-in and even home runs.  On-Base Percentage is everything because runs generate wins and wins are everything.


Unable to compete under conventional means and with nothing to lose except his job and his reputation, Beane takes a chance on statistics-based-baseball (popularly known as Sabermetrics).  Beane also has a personal reason in this radical concept since he was a former baseball prodigy who looked like a hall-of-famer and instead flamed out.  Given a false sense of his own worth, Beane wants to see value on paper and never again fall for the same deceptions.  As Beane and Brandt’s new strategy struggles in the face of opposition from manager Art Howe (Philip Seymour Hoffman), skeptical scouts, and the ire of every single sports pundit, the two risk everything on players who have tweaked nerves, funny pitch delivery, and old legs.

Moneyball skillfully plays with the question of how baseball can remain fun if it’s boiled down to a science.  If everything is just a statistic, and the statistics celebrating walks while ruling out staples like base-stealing and bunting, then how much is left for us to enjoy?  Doesn’t science remove the poetry of a game when a batter’s stance and poise is irrelevant when compared to how many walks he draws?  Those questions may bother a fan, but Billy Beane needs to win not just for his career but to change the game in way he never could as a player.  Moneyball is a sports underdog story presented in a more thoughtful manner than simply “Must win championship.”


Miller does a tremendous job taking complicated ideas and delivers them in an easily-accessible drama.  Steve Zaillian and Aaron Sorkin’s script distills the ideas and bullet points of Lewis’ book and turns them into charming quips and shorthand that will work for baseball fans and non-fans alike.  More impressive is that Miller doesn’t rely on graphics or playful visual aids to explain the stats and why they matter.  Sharp, succinct dialogue and some close-ups on computer monitors is all he needs to make his point.  There’s enough confidence in the story, the themes, the humor, and the performances that big visual flourishes like numbers running across the screen or expensive animated graphics are unnecessary.  Moneyball is only frustrating when it betrays its self-assured tone and drags in the middle when the story drives home the point that the baseball establishment thinks Beane is a lunatic, and a cloying relationship between Beane and his daughter where she writes him a song to cheer him up.  It certainly doesn’t need a character at the end summing up the result of Beane’s experiment.

But these shortcomings aren’t to the greater detriment of the picture.  Moneyball keeps cool even when it comes to its complicated climax and the A’s are going for the longest winning-streak in major league history.  It’s an unexpected crystallization of how statistics don’t kill our enjoyment of baseball.  If Beane and Brandt were truly heartless stat-hounds, the streak would be meaningless to them as would a championship beyond increased revenues to buy more players.  Beane may be able to fool himself that he doesn’t care about championship rings or win-streaks or anything beyond proving his point, but he’s as excited as the rest of us when he watches Scott Hatteberg (Chris Pratt), a washed-up catcher turned first basemen that every other team had given up on, comes to the plate.


Science may beat out superstition but that doesn’t mean it destroys awe or excitement.  Sure, “Casey at the Bat” would lose some of its poetic power if “Mighty Casey has struck out” was changed to “Mighty Casey struck out because he didn’t realize he was statistically more likely to hit pitches that were up-and-in than down-and-away.”  But intangibles can’t be destroyed by statistics.  Does an Athletics fan feel less joy if a game-winning home run comes off the bat of Scott Hatteberg rather than a Jason Giambi?  Is a strikeout any less of a victory if it comes off the arm of Chad Bradford rather than Jason Isringhausen?  Science doesn’t remove mystique and it doesn’t diminish a victory.  It just means you don’t write off a hitter if he has an unattractive girlfriend and you certainly don’t write off Moneyball because you think you don’t like sports movies.  It’s much more than another underdog story (although I don’t have the stats to prove it).

Sleeping Beauty (2011)

Julia Leigh’s Sleeping Beauty invites us into a world which unintentionally undoes its own effect.  Ordinarily, the sex acts and humiliation would shock us, but we’re asked to accept a reality in which every character passively accepts these depraved circumstances.  The characters have perfectly justifiable reasons for their detachment but their ennui carries over to the audience due to Leigh’s sparse approach, seductive visuals, and Emily Browning’s brave but withdrawn performance.  We become numb like the film’s protagonist and we disconnect from any emotional attachment.

Sleeping Beauty opens under the pretense that Lucy (Emily Browning) is desperate for money.  She’s working four jobs including prostitution and she still can’t pay her rent.  Either she has the worst student loan payment plan of all time or she’s a peculiar kind of submissive.  Lucy isn’t a character who wants to be in control by being out of control, but wants to emotionally disappear from the world by quietly serving others.  One of the clearest examples of her servitude is when she’s offered a job by Clara (Rachael Blake).  Clara’s business offers wealthy clients a highly specific form of sexual service.  In the scene, Lucy is examined in a dark and disturbing way that’s highly reminiscent of when potential buyers went to slave markets and inspected people as if they were cattle.


At first, Lucy is just a lingerie-clad servant, but then she’s asked to engage in an even more peculiar (and lucrative) fetish.  Lucy willingly allows herself to be drugged and have wealthy old men do whatever they want to her while she sleeps (“except penetration”, as Clara reminds her clients).  It’s not much distance from the stupor Lucy’s usually in except for her time with Birdman (Ewen Leslie), someone for whom she cares and not merely serves.

Unlike Shame, Lucy’s meaningless sex isn’t an addiction tearing her apart nor does Leigh attempt to show her reaching new depths of depravity.  Instead, Leigh wants to keep the tone nice and even in order to show the monotony, coldness, and emptiness of Lucy’s life.  The movie plays almost entirely without music, uses long takes filled with vivid colors and muted performances, and Leigh’s direction barely speaks above a whisper.  We are voyeurs to this unusual world but Sleeping Beauty could care less whether we’re watching or not.


Browning plays perfectly to the film’s silent void so it’s difficult to tell if it’s a “good” performance.  Lucy doesn’t play a wide range of emotions and she’s not supposed to.  Sleeping Beauty forbids her from even providing subtle hints to how the character’s feeling except when there’s a clear break in her pristine exterior.  She’s a porcelain doll for the world to use as it sees fit and her central drive is to feel nothing and she only gets to show any personality and vitality during her time with Birdman.  But while it’s not a big performance, it is undeniably a fearless one.  Browning lays herself bare and then she lets naked, disgusting old men climb use her body in disturbing ways.

The movie perfectly mirrors its protagonist and does its best to put us in her mindset.  Sleeping Beauty is outwardly cold and captivating but its soul is dark, twisted, and in the distance.

The Ides Of March

We’re not inherently jaded about politics.  You can’t have your idealism torn down if nothing was built in the first place.  The 2008 election of Barack Obama promoted that idealism and gave people hope (the giant posters emblazoned with the word “Hope” may have had something to do with it).  But we were all deceived when reality came crashing in and The Ides of March lays the blame not on our political system or even our politicians but on us.  And when we realize that we can’t do anything larger than ourselves, we begin to think only of ourselves.  Director George Clooney (who also co-wrote the screenplay and co-stars in the film) avoids being preachy or heavy-handed, but his light-touch fails to leave a lasting impact.


Press secretary Steven Myers (Ryan Gosling) is a true believer in his Presidential candidate Mike Morris (Clooney).  Steven has worked on numerous campaigns, he’s well-liked by the press corps, and he’s damn good at his job.  Even Tom Duffy (Paul Giamatti), the campaign director of Morris’ opponent, wants to steal him away. Working alongside veteran campaign director Paul Zara (Philip Seymour Hoffman), Steven is confident they’ll get Morris elected and change the country for the better.  But when Steven betrays his own ideals, it starts a chain reaction which unravels his faith and makes him choke on the delicious Mike Morris Kool-Aid.


Drawing Morris’ campaign so close to Obama’s is a double-edged sword.  On the one hand, Obama is the perfect representation of how a country can project their hopes and dreams onto a handsome, well-spoken, and intellectual individual.  But using the imagery of Obama’s campaign, from a riff on the famous Shepard Fairey poster to using the Gotham font of the campaign’s banners, makes the film feel dated and confined to a criticism of an individual rather than human condition.  Additionally, the Morris/Obama comparison becomes further complicated by the scandalous revelation about Morris which doesn’t come close to coinciding with any rumor associated with Obama.

But the idea of losing your belief in a political figure perfectly captures the zeitgeist.  At one point, campaign worker Ben (Max Minghella) notes that in the general election, the inexperienced candidate almost always beats out his veteran opponent.  The implication is that the American public prefers the devil they don’t know because maybe, just maybe, he won’t be a devil.  It’s the inevitable result of identity politics and American reverence of “The Individual”: One man can save the country because that’s how heroic narratives are supposed to work.  Hardly a profound realization, but it’s a smart way for Clooney to make his comment without coming off as Redford-esque (i.e. preachy and pedantic).


The Ides of March manages the difficult balancing act of exploring the current state of our politics and seeing how it relates to the American pscyhe.  When characters talk about the campaign, they talk about poll numbers instead of policy.  At one point, Steven tries to pitch Morris on giving kids a free ride to college in exchange for mandatory two-year service.  “Older voters will like it because it doesn’t affect them,” Steven explains, “and those who would be against it won’t be old enough to vote.”  It’s not the policy that gets Steven excited, it’s the political victory it could deliver.

But with characters who are supposed to be political sharks, as an audience we must delude ourselves that they would make such obvious mistakes.  Steven takes a meeting he shouldn’t.  Paul believes that he can get senator Thompson (Jeffrey Wright) to deliver his delegates and essentially the White House because if Morris can win the Democratic Primary, he can beat the weak GOP candidate.  Morris thinks he’s a man of integrity and dignity and doesn’t want to make a backroom deal with Thompson in order to win Ohio.  Even Clooney gets in on the self-deception as he shows his bias towards journalists.  The only character who seems to truly understand politics and getting at the truth is cynical New York Times reporter Ida Horowicz (Marisa Tomei).  It’s an understandable bias when you consider that Clooney’s father is a journalist and Clooney made a loving tribute to Edward R. Murrow with Good Night and Good Luck.


espite the clever crafting of his central theme, Clooney never quite lands the knockout punch.  Gosling, Hoffman, and Giamatti all remind us once again why they’re some of the best actors working today, and even Evan Rachel Wood, who usually turns me off a movie, makes her role as an intern on Morris’ campaign more than a plot point.  The cinematography is sharp, the pacing is lively, and while the dialogue occasionally gets a little Sorkin-esque, it’s a well-written drama.

Strangely, these strong elements never come together to deliver the impact that leaves the film spinning in your mind.  When I walked out of The Ides of March, I felt it was good, but that the movie contradicted itself.  How could Steven criticize the American people’s obsession with personality rather than policy when he’s just as enamored of Morris’ character?  But when cast inside the notion of politics, and perhaps even human nature, as the art deceptive, the film gels together.

Or maybe I’m just kidding myself.

Friday, September 16, 2011

Jane Eyre (2011)

When I was at school, I had a lot of trouble with the classics. Not all of them though, Bram Stoker, Lovecraft and Mary Shelly weren’t a problem, but Daniel Defoe, Jane Austin and Charlotte Bronte I struggled with.

Why? I’m not quite sure, especially after seeing Cary Fukunaga’s adaptation. It’s given me an entirely different perspective on this 19th century novel, visualising it in such gothic splendour that there wasn’t a moment during the film’s 120 minutes that my heart simply didn’t skip a beat.

Jane Eyre

Mia Wasikowska plays the title role of Jane who flees Thornfield Hall, where she works as a governess for Edward Fairfax Rochester’s (Michael Fassbender) young daughter, Adèle Varens. Despite her reclusiveness and Rochester’s impulsive nature, the two fall in love, but unknown to her is the dark secret he has kept hidden. It’s inevitable revelation waiting to destroy them both.

Jane finds shelter in the home of a kind clergyman, St. John Rivers (Jamie Bell), and his family. There she takes on a new job while she recuperates, but knows only too well that one day she will have to face it all, including her beloved Rochester.

Told in flashbacks, Fukunaga pieces together a story I couldn’t tear my eyes away from, not even for a second. Although he moved the time period up by a few years to improve on the costumes, Jane Eyre emerges as the film I always wanted to see in my mind when reading the book.

It’s just so hard to contain the emotions as we see Jane making her way back to Thornfield Hall, only to discover the horror of what happened during her time away. It’s a breathtaking film, based on a story I am only now starting to understand and appreciate.


The performances are stunning; Wasikowska is everything you could ask for here and Fassbender is magnificent as the frighteningly charming Rochester. I was captivated by the cinematography and score as well. Never have the grey skies and wet fields looked as achingly beautiful as they have in Jane Eyre and as Dario Marianelli’s score worked its magic it was Jack Liebeck’s masterful violin playing that moved me quietly and peacefully to tears.

Needless to say, Jane Eyre has renewed my interest in classic literature and in no time at all I was thumbing through the fiction section at my local library under “B” to relieve those moments I had only just experienced on the screen.

Monday, September 12, 2011

Moneyball (2011)


As far as sports go, for whatever reason I’ve never found myself able to watch baseball for prolonged periods of time. Yet when it comes to the world of sports films, I’ve always found myself drawn more towards the ones concerning that very one. And Moneyball is yet another title to add to the pantheon of baseball films that manage to entertain, but not wildly so.

As a whole, the story offers no real surprises. This is partly due to it being based in truth, partly due to that truth being turned into a book and partly due to it being fairly predictable, even if you’re unaware of the story behind it. But a solid script from Steven Zaillian (Schindler’s List) and Aaron Sorkin (The Social Network), coupled with competent direction from Bennett Miller (Capote), helps the film rise a notch or two above the typical underdog story. Overall, it’s a ride that we’ve taken before. But it was a nice ride then, and it’s certainly a nice ride now.

Though you really can’t help but wonder what Moneyball would be like if they had infused it with a bit more of the punch that both the writers and director have had in their previous projects. Granted, it wasn’t a story that necessarily called for the vast amounts of emotion and turmoil that they’ve played around with, but even the briefest look at their filmographies says that they’re not afraid to take bolder chances.  As it stands, Moneyball is absolutely fine, but also incredibly safe. And maybe that’s not a problem as much as it is an observation.

As far as the cast goes, nobody really goes above and beyond, though that isn’t to say the performances are weak. The most surprising one of the bunch must has to come from Jonah Hill, who casts off the associations placed on him after Superbad to portray a much more soft-spoken, fairly serious (with the exception of a few moments here and there) and very intelligent character. As for Brad Pitt, well…he’s Brad Pitt. However, that’s not a bad thing, and for the most part he’s always a welcomed presence on the screen, and Moneyball is no different. He is very much a leading man, and he leads this film as well as he does any other.

But as solid as the cast may be, they can’t do much to save a lagging second act. Miller is no stranger to films with slower pacing (Capote is a testament to this), and Moneyball seems to get progressively slower as it goes. By the time the regular season starts up, the pace really drags. The story and character keeps eyes to the screen, but unfortunately it also helps bring a rise in clock-watching, and you start wishing that Pitt and Hill’s grand idea would get a start already. Thankfully, it does, and things pick up again. But that lull right smack-dab in the middle is a serious blemish. If Miller is making consciously making these choices, then more power to him. But he should really learn to pick his battles.

In the end, Moneyball is a decent sports drama. Baseball fans will be into it, non-baseball fans can probably find something to enjoy about it, too.  But if you’re a fan or Aaron Sorkin, Steven Zaillian, or Bennett Miller, be warned: they do an admirable job with their respective duties but don’t quite go above and beyond.  It doesn’t do anything new, and it might not even be one that stays with you long after it’s over, but that’s not such a bad thing as long as it does its job.

Sunday, September 11, 2011

The Entitled (2011)

Kevin Zegers of the recent FROZEN and one of my guilty pleasures, IT'S A BOY GIRL THING, stars in the low-profile but effective Canadian thriller THE ENTITLED (2011).  It isn't Hitchcock, but with a capable cast and an edgy script that keeps us wondering what'll happen next, I wasn't complaining.

Zegers plays Paul Dynan, a bicycle courier working his way through college and trying to better himself for the benefit of his sick mother, who can't afford her pills and is about to get thrown out of her house.  Putting his sharp wits to work, Paul devises a scheme to kidnap three rich kids (Dustin Milligan, Laura Vandervoort, John Bregar) and squeeze their dads for a million bucks apiece.  But his two mentally unstable accomplices, Dean (Devon Bostick) and Jenna (Tatiana Maslany), are more interested in anarchy than money and throw a monkey wrench into the works.

What seems at first like a simple and not that exciting story gets more tense and unpredictable as Paul's plan goes haywire.  With the three hostages bound and blindfolded in a basement while their dads scramble to transfer funds into Paul's account, Dean and Jenna can't resist toying with these privileged progeny and bringing them down a peg or two.  As you might guess, one of them goes too far and suddenly Paul's intention of returning the three spoiled rich kids unharmed is violently derailed.  This is where the story starts getting more interesting.

Meanwhile, the frantic fathers wait anxiously by the phone and eventually start going at each other with suspicions and accusations.  This part of the film resembles a cracking one-act play with some powerful actors--Ray Liotta, Stephen McHattie, and Victor Garber (TITANIC)--getting steadily more intense and watchable.  The drama increases when one of them can't come up with his million and devises his own sneaky scheme to dupe one of the others into paying it.

While Liotta and McHattie appear to be walking through their roles in the beginning, they start to bring it on after things heat up.  Garber enters the scene later and adds a whole new dimension when his character discovers that the others have been deceiving him about the situation.  Before long, he--and we--begin to suspect that one of the others might even be in on the whole kidnapping plot himself.

The film is nice-looking and director Aaron Woodley's style is clean and unobtrusive.  Writer William Morrissey maintains a deliberate pace throughout and never rushes things, letting the twists and turns of the plot hold our interest till the end.  With three separate dramatic situations going on concurrently--the desperate fathers whose friendship is falling apart over money, the kidnappers with vastly conflicting interests, and the terrified hostages trying to escape with their lives--the story generates a fair amount of suspense without resorting to graphic violence or shock.

The DVD from Anchor Bay is in 2.40:1 anamorphic widescreen with English 5.1 and Spanish mono.  Subtitles are in English and Spanish.  Bonuses consist of a behind-the-scenes featurette and an alternate ending.

THE ENTITLED isn't what I'd call a "riveting" or "pulse-pounding" experience, nor does it really aspire to be.  It's just a slick, engrossing minor thriller that's good for a couple of hours of popcorn-munching entertainment.

Saturday, September 10, 2011

Heartbeats (2011)

Despite being his sophomore feature, 22 year old Xavier Dolan's Heartbeats is the director's first film to be released in the United States. He caused quite a critical splash last year with his debut film, I Killed My Mother, but despite being picked up for distribution by Regent Releasing, the film has yet to see a US release outside of a few festival screenings.

I was mixed on I Killed My Mother, which I saw last year in conjunction with the RiverRun Film Festival. It was a strong and promising debut, but I found it almost self consciously stylish. Dolan displayed a filmmaking prowess beyond his years, but it didn't seem as if he had quite figured out how to convey everything that he wanted to convey. It was a solid first film, with room for improvement and growth in the future. It would take a second film to really see what this kid was made out of.

Not even a year later, along comes Heartbeats (a weaker title than the original French, Les Amours Imaginaires)- which, frustratingly, represents both a step forward and a dogged stagnation in Dolan's craft, who seems trapped by his own inspirations.

Xavier Dolan as FRANCIS, Niels Schneider as NICOLAS and Monia Chokri as MARIE in HEARTBEATS directed by Xavier Dolan. Photo Credit: © Mifilifilms Inc. An IFC Films release

Dolan stars as gay twenty-something, Francis, who along with his best friend, Marie (Monia Chokri) meet an alluring and enigmatic stranger, Nicolas (Niels Schneider) at a party and become hopelessly infatuated. Marie falls deeply in love and even begins a relationship with Francis, unaware that Francis has developed feelings of his own. But it soon becomes clear that both of them are in competition for the same man, and the three of them form a strange triangle that threatens to destroy Francis and Marie's friendship even as it unites them all in ways they could have never expected.

As he did in I Killed My Mother, Dolan displays a keen insight into human relationships, and at its core, Heartbeats is a devastating exploration of the complexities and absurdities of love. As a writer, Dolan has a way of conveying emotions with a sharpness that often takes you by surprise. Here, his examination of mixed signals and misunderstandings is both brutally honest and surprisingly funny. He knows how to get to the root of a situation with great wit and little nonsense, exposing the truth of a situation with an almost painful grace.

Niels Schneider as NICOLAS in HEARTBEATS directed by Xavier Dolan.
Photo Credit: © Mifilifilms Inc. An IFC Films release

As a director, however, the opposite is often true, and therein lies my problem with Dolan. He is so infatuated with his own inspirations that it becomes a stylistic stumbling block. He is obviously enamored with the work of the likes of Wong Kar-Wai and Pedro Almodovar, and he fills Heartbeats with long, stylized sequences of intoxicating slow motion set to dreamy and haunting music. But whereas in the films of Wong and Almodovar such sequences flow naturally with the rest of the film, here they almost seem out of place, as if they have been forced into the film with no real purpose or context other than the filmmaker's own love of their sources. It is this stubborn adherence to the style of his idols that is preventing Dolan from blossoming as his own filmmaker. Right now his voice is lost amid the emulations of stronger and more experienced filmmakers. While directors like Quentin Tarantino have certainly made very successful careers out of emulating their inspirations, the difference is that Tarantino has really worked to make his inspirations his own, absorbing it all and transforming it into something that transcends their original sources. Dolan, on the other hand, seems engulfed by them, his unique voice lost amid the overwhelming homages.

He is obviously a talented filmmaker with something to say, but I want to know more about who he is as an artist, not the artists that inspire him. I've seen films by Wong Kar-Wai and Pedro Almodovar - they still make them regularly. I want to see something new, I want to see something by Xavier Dolan. Having inspirations that inform your work is one thing, but relying on them completely for your style is something else. It is for that reason that I'm not fully on the Dolan bandwagon just yet. Until he learns to rely less heavily on his muses, he will never grow as an artist, but the potential is obviously there in flashes of brilliance beneath the surface. He just needs to work on developing his own unique voice to truly come into his own.